
A recent High Court decision has highlighted the importance of correctly implemented service entity arrangements in medical and healthcare practices. The court’s ruling in the Uber case ([2026] HCA 40) has significant implications for practices, as it may lead to contractors being treated as employees for payroll tax purposes.
The key to avoiding an Uber-like outcome is to ensure that service entity arrangements are correctly implemented and follow the Australian Taxation Office’s (ATO) ruling (TR 2006/2). This can be achieved by using a Tenant Doctor arrangement, where the practice provides services and practitioners run their own independent practices.
Service Fee Calculators and Accounting Systems
A practice’s service fee calculator and accounting systems can create evidence against the practice or prove that it is operating correctly. It is essential to review these systems to ensure they are compliant with the ATO’s ruling and do not suggest that the practice is controlling the practitioners’ money or setting their fees.
A technology label alone will not determine the outcome; how the arrangement works in practice is what matters. Practitioners should be free to present their own independent practice to patients, and the practice should not dictate how they bill or practice. A practice-wide fee decision, such as moving all doctors to bulk billing overnight, can be used against the practice if doctors are not seen to be free to set their own fees.
Compliant Service Entities
The good news is that most practices can close any gaps in their systems without rebuilding their business. The foundation is a correctly implemented service entity arrangement, where practitioners control their own money, set their own fees, and are free to practice independently.
To achieve this, practices can take four practical steps: let practitioners control their own money, let them set their own fees, use accreditation and policies for quality and safety only, and automate the numbers. By doing so, practices can ensure they are compliant with the ATO’s ruling and avoid potential payroll tax issues.
A service fee calculator, such as the Doctors Pay (Service Fee) Calculator, can help practices achieve this. The calculator has been reviewed by registered tax agents and lawyers and has been tested through audits and rulings. However, it is essential to note that each practice should seek independent legal and taxation advice before acting on these matters.
The ruling states that a service entity arrangement must be genuinely independent and not controlled by the practice. This means that practitioners must be free to set their own fees, control their own money, and practice independently.
Read Also: Hypnotherapy helps with anxiety disorders
In addition to the ATO’s ruling, the Australian Taxation Office website provides further information on service entity arrangements and payroll tax.
Avoiding Payroll Tax Issues
It is essential to take action now, as the consequences of non-compliance can be significant, as seen in the Uber case.
The source does not explicitly state that the ruling provides examples of implementation.
Getting it right also gives practices clean numbers for the practice valuation they may need when the capital gains tax changes start on 1 July 2027. In Australia, observations since 1992 have shown what works and what does not.
Checking Uber Readiness
Eight quick checks can help determine if a practice is Uber-ready. Most arrangements were set up before the Uber decision, and software disclaimers usually leave compliance to the practice. Calculators often sit outside an adviser’s scope, making it essential to review them independently.
Compliance Review and Next Steps
A compliance review should include checking if the service fee calculator has had an independent legal and registered tax agent review. The books should be reviewed to ensure calculations match tax and accounting records. Invoices should be checked to ensure they are valid tax invoices, and bank reconciliations should be automated or done by hand each pay run.
Reimbursements and consumables should be recovered, and practitioners should not be overpaid. BAS and tax figures should be reconcilable for each practitioner. Pooled payments should be avoided, as they can suggest the practice controls the money. Fee setting and billing prompts should not be dictated by the practice, and practitioners should be free to set their own fees and billing.
By working through the 8 checks with their accountant and lawyer, most practices find the gaps are small and quick to close, resulting in less admin, cleaner numbers, and peace of mind for the whole team.